Comparison
Agency Pilot vs spreadsheets
Nearly every agency starts in a spreadsheet, and a surprising number should stay there a while longer than they think.
A spreadsheet is free, instant, infinitely flexible and understood by everyone you will ever hire. Those are real advantages and software vendors are strangely reluctant to say so.
What a spreadsheet cannot do is enforce anything. It cannot stop a client seeing another client's row, guarantee that a process was followed, notice that nobody has updated a status in three weeks, or tell you who changed a number. Every one of those is handled by somebody remembering to be careful.
So the question is not which tool is better. It is whether you have reached the point where remembering to be careful has become a job in itself. That point usually arrives somewhere between eight and fifteen clients, and it arrives as a feeling — that you are the integration layer holding everything together — rather than as an event.
Side by side
The differences that actually decide it
| Agency Pilot | Spreadsheets | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to start | $49/mo | Effectively free |
| Set-up time | An afternoon | Minutes |
| Flexibility | Structured around clients | Total — anything you can imagine |
| Client can log in and see only their own data | Enforced in the database | A separate file per client, maintained by hand |
| Automatic ranking data | Geo grid scans on demand | Pasted in manually |
| Processes that create real tasks | ||
| Automations and notifications | Scripts, if someone maintains them | |
| Audit trail of who changed what | Version history, if nobody duplicates the file | |
| Scale ceiling | Plan limits | Up to 10 million cells or 18,278 columns in Google Sheets |
| Works when you are on holiday | Anyone can pick it up | Depends who built it |
Spreadsheets figures taken from their own published pages on 17 September 2026. Pricing and features change — check the sources below before making a decision on them.
Stay in the spreadsheet if
- You have a handful of clients and you are the only person touching the file. The overhead of software is real and you would be paying it for nothing.
- Your processes are still changing weekly. Structure is a cost when you do not yet know what the structure should be, and a spreadsheet absorbs change for free.
- You are testing a service line you may drop in two months.
- Cash is genuinely tight. $49 a month is not nothing when you are starting, and there is no shame in waiting.
- What you actually need is a better spreadsheet, not a different category of tool. Sometimes the answer is one afternoon of cleanup.
Move when
- Clients start asking to see things. The moment you want a client looking at their own data, a spreadsheet becomes a file you have to maintain a sanitised copy of — and one bad share link away from a serious problem.
- You hire someone. A spreadsheet that only its author understands is not a system, it is a dependency, and it becomes visible the first week someone else needs to use it.
- You are pasting ranking data in by hand. That is not a data-entry problem, it is an hour a week you will never get back.
- You have started keeping a second spreadsheet to track the first one. This is the reliable signal.
- Something was missed and nobody can work out how. Spreadsheets have no memory of intent — they cannot tell you the step that did not happen.
Sources
Think something here is out of date or unfair? Tell us and we will correct it.
Put your agency on autopilot
Start a 14-day trial with 300 credits. Add your first client and send an onboarding link today.